The yield on Germany’s 10-year government bond fell to a record low against comparable swap rates, signaling investor concern over potential increases in government borrowing. This shift comes as policymakers discuss boosting defense spending, potentially requiring significant new debt issuance.
Table Content:
Swap Spreads Signal Rising Borrowing Costs
The spread between the 10-year German bund yield and the corresponding swap rate widened to five basis points, the largest gap since 2007. This metric, known as the swap spread, is a key indicator of future bond issuance. A widening spread often suggests that the market anticipates increased government borrowing, which can put downward pressure on bond prices and drive yields higher. While Germany’s historically low debt levels provide room for increased borrowing, investors demand higher yields to compensate for the increased risk associated with a larger debt load.
Political Landscape Fuels Uncertainty
The recent German federal election resulted in no single party securing a two-thirds majority, a requirement for amending constitutional limits on borrowing. Discussions are underway between the Christian Democrats, led by Chancellor-in-waiting Friedrich Merz, and the Social Democrats to potentially approve up to €200 billion ($209 billion) in new spending before the new parliament convenes. This potential surge in borrowing, largely driven by proposed increases in defense spending, has heightened market sensitivity to future bond supply.
Citigroup analysts highlight the significance of these political developments, noting that the potential for increased borrowing “keeps the near-term spotlight on funding for defense, which looks set to weigh further on swap spreads.” The urgency stems from pressure to bolster military capabilities in response to geopolitical events, particularly the ongoing conflict in Ukraine.
Pressure Mounts on European Funding
ING Bank strategists emphasize the broader European context, stating that “under geopolitical pressure, politicians are exploring funding options for a military build-up, which validates the market’s cautious approach amid looming supply concerns.” The European Central Bank’s ongoing reduction of its bond holdings further exacerbates the situation, increasing the volume of bonds that private investors must absorb.
Bloomberg cross-asset strategist Ven Ram points out the significant steepening of the yield curve between two- and 30-year German bonds, anticipating a permanent increase in debt funding across the Eurozone.
Debt Brake Reform Faces Challenges
Despite the political momentum, significant hurdles remain. Implementing reforms to Germany’s strict fiscal rules, known as the “debt brake,” faces opposition from various political factions, raising doubts about the feasibility of swift changes. Commerzbank’s head of rates and credit research, Christoph Rieger, cautions that setbacks are “very likely,” and the initial market reaction might be overly optimistic.
Market Implications and Outlook
Despite the challenges, recent statements from German politicians suggest a growing commitment to finding a solution. Danske Bank analyst Rune Johansen estimates the probability of a debt brake reform has risen to 70% following comments from Merz, indicating a strong push to address the issue. This increased likelihood of reform, coupled with the anticipated supply-demand imbalance in the German bond market, leads Johansen to expect further tightening of German asset swap spreads. This signals a potential for German government bonds to cheapen relative to swaps as borrowing increases. The evolving political and economic landscape will continue to influence investor sentiment and drive fluctuations in the German bond market.
